Page 1 of 1

Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 11:52 am
by evanbottcher
Hi folks,

I've never loved the front inboard calipers on the Sud. The race car for years has had outboard fronts, and therefore no handbrake at all. For our four-door I'd like to retain the front inboard calipers but find some solution to have a decent rear handbrake. Has anyone ever tackled this problem? Is there *any* rear disc with integral handbrake that's an easy mod?

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 1:07 pm
by JetJackson
alfa 33? ;-)

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 1:09 pm
by evanbottcher
Did they come with disc rear end? I'd heard that there was a European model that had disc rear, but unlikely to find it in Australia and I think quite different arrangement for the rear suspension arms.

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 5:11 pm
by PETROLHEAD
If Aus is anything like the UK, the only disc rear 33 was the P4.

There have been alternative solutions found, the simplest is probably to adapt a different caliper to your sud disc set up, or add a "spot" brake caliper by someone such as HiSpec or willwood etc etc


I have a different solution but better not go into that! :shock:

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 7:12 pm
by junior
The solution on my car is mini rear drums, but the cable run is poor.

I am trying to improve it, oh and the brake cylinders are upside down so bleeding may be an issue later. :?

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 7:14 pm
by 902a
There were 33 16V with rear discs and handbrake calipers in germany. I use them at my sprint together with a 905 (33 8V) rear axle, but the calipers are quite heavy..
16VBremse.jpg
Ali

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 7:24 pm
by PETROLHEAD

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 9:29 pm
by junior
Wow , never heard of spot callipers. Very interesting.

With a decent location to hang them the rest should be very easy and reliable.

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 11:14 pm
by Spacenut
Unfortunately spot calipers aren't very effective on saloon cars, they are mainly designed for "kit" cars, where "kit" has a very specific meaning. Locatorfields! Which only weigh in at around 550 kg.

One production handbrake caliper that has been suggested to me in the past is the Fiat X1/9, which is a single pot sliding caliper so is marginally more effective than the Alfasud caliper. Lancia Delta handbrake calipers have also been re-purposed in the past (probably a very similar design to the Fiat, if not identical)

A near identical type of handbrake caliper to the Alfasud (mechanical operation of the inboard piston only, with manual adjustment) is fitted to the Alfetta GTV (inboard) and the Ferrari 308 (outboard).

For best possible efficiency there are plenty of moderns that use handbrake calipers, Audis seem to be a popular choice.

Lauren

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 11:15 pm
by Spacenut
PS - Locaterfields = Locost/Caterham/Westfield, i.e. any old Lotus 7 clone :D

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 11:37 pm
by PETROLHEAD
Spacenut wrote:Unfortunately spot calipers aren't very effective on saloon cars, they are mainly designed for "kit" cars, where "kit" has a very specific meaning. Locatorfields! Which only weigh in at around 550 kg.

Righto Lauren, lesson learned, not really up to the job of an E brake as such, and might not be up to scratch on an mot brake tester either then?



For best possible efficiency there are plenty of moderns that use handbrake calipers, Audis seem to be a popular choice.

Lauren
I have a pair of the VAG rear handbrake calipers that i bought to have a mess with myself some time ago, and they looked to me like a simple bracket and they'd work a treat. Similar to the ones pictured below, (only mine are red!) and up for grabs since i have a different plan now?

VAG REAR CALIPER.jpg

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2016 9:14 am
by Alfasixnut
As a possible thought....I used the rear callipers from the 164 at the rear of the 6C (where it acted on the front discs - which was now at the back...). That gave a good cable operated handbrake.

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2016 8:40 pm
by Kegsti66
Spacenut wrote:PS - Locaterfields = Locost/Caterham/Westfield, i.e. any old Lotus 7 clone :D

Like it :lol:

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Wed Nov 09, 2016 10:16 pm
by Spacenut
petrolhead wrote:
Spacenut wrote:Unfortunately spot calipers aren't very effective on saloon cars, they are mainly designed for "kit" cars, where "kit" has a very specific meaning. Locatorfields! Which only weigh in at around 550 kg.

Righto Lauren, lesson learned, not really up to the job of an E brake as such, and might not be up to scratch on an mot brake tester either then?



For best possible efficiency there are plenty of moderns that use handbrake calipers, Audis seem to be a popular choice.

Lauren
I have a pair of the VAG rear handbrake calipers that i bought to have a mess with myself some time ago, and they looked to me like a simple bracket and they'd work a treat. Similar to the ones pictured below, (only mine are red!) and up for grabs since i have a different plan now?

VAG REAR CALIPER.jpg
Yes, I think spot calipers might struggle on an MoT test, although in theory the mass of the car shouldn't make a difference on the rollers...

VAG caliper looks perfect for the job - single pot sliding caliper, just the ticket!

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Wed Nov 09, 2016 10:36 pm
by KevJTD
Spacenut wrote:
petrolhead wrote:
Spacenut wrote:Unfortunately spot calipers aren't very effective on saloon cars, they are mainly designed for "kit" cars, where "kit" has a very specific meaning. Locatorfields! Which only weigh in at around 550 kg.

Righto Lauren, lesson learned, not really up to the job of an E brake as such, and might not be up to scratch on an mot brake tester either then?



For best possible efficiency there are plenty of moderns that use handbrake calipers, Audis seem to be a popular choice.

Lauren
I have a pair of the VAG rear handbrake calipers that i bought to have a mess with myself some time ago, and they looked to me like a simple bracket and they'd work a treat. Similar to the ones pictured below, (only mine are red!) and up for grabs since i have a different plan now?

VAG REAR CALIPER.jpg
Yes, I think spot calipers might struggle on an MoT test, although in theory the mass of the car shouldn't make a difference on the rollers...

VAG caliper looks perfect for the job - single pot sliding caliper, just the ticket!
trouble is the hand brake needs to work to a % of the cars weight...so the heavier the car the more force it needs to register on the rollers, even though as you hinted at, more body weight doesn't equal more force necessarily

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2016 10:17 pm
by Spacenut
Quite right - which sort of rules out aftermarket spot calipers I think. However, a quick search of the Interweb has turned up quite a few viable replacements, how about the rear calipers from a 916 GTV or 147? With a bit of luck you should be able to adapt the handbrake lever and cables from a late model Sprint or 33...

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Mon Nov 14, 2016 7:35 pm
by PETROLHEAD
I also have a pair of pug 206gti rear calipers which could be good,

Alloy caliper but cast pad carrier. They're not heavy at all and the mounts look quite close too :P

I doubt if I'll use either of them now, so holla if anyone fancies them :P

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Tue Nov 15, 2016 2:30 pm
by Simonsud
Down side with Peugeot calipers is the hand brake is useless when it's working properly and pads are very thin when new .On the plus side they are light and compact

Re: Alternative handbrake for Sud

Posted: Wed Nov 16, 2016 2:45 pm
by PETROLHEAD
Simonsud wrote:Down side with Peugeot calipers is the hand brake is useless when it's working properly
:lol: :lol: :lol:

That could be true Simon